How Do I Know If My IUL Is Structured Correctly?

Short answerAn indexed universal life (IUL) policy is structured correctly when its premium, death benefit and death benefit option match your goal and the policy's current in-force illustration shows coverage lasting to your target age at a premium you can keep paying. The most common signs of a poorly structured IUL are paying only the minimum or target premium, a death benefit much larger than the goal requires, and an in-force illustration that shows the policy lapsing early. You can check all of this for free by requesting an in-force illustration from your insurer and comparing it with your annual statement.

Why do so many IULs end up structured wrong?

An IUL is flexible life insurance, and that flexibility cuts both ways. The same contract can be designed mainly for death benefit protection or mainly for cash value accumulation, and the design choices made at purchase decide how much of each premium dollar goes to charges versus cash value.

Three things commonly push a policy off course:

  • The design didn’t match the goal. A policy bought to build cash value for later income is sometimes sold with a large death benefit and a low premium, which maximizes the cost of insurance deduction and leaves little to accumulate.
  • Assumptions changed. The Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance warned in a December 3, 2021 consumer alert that “if charges increase or interest rates decrease, the cash value may not be sufficient to cover the costs of the contract over time.”
  • Nobody looked at it again. The same Wisconsin alert notes that many universal life owners “found that their policies had lapsed (were no longer in effect) with little to no value” after years of paying premiums.

None of this means IUL is a bad product. It means an IUL is a contract that needs the right design up front and an annual check-up afterward.

What are the 7 warning signs your IUL isn’t structured correctly?

#Warning signWhere to lookFixes to ask about
1You pay only the minimum or target premium on an accumulation-focused policyPremium notice; original illustrationHigher planned premium, or a lower death benefit
2Death benefit is much larger than your goal requiresPolicy data pageReduce face amount (check for surrender charges first)
3Death benefit option was never revisitedPolicy data page (Option A/B or level/increasing)Ask whether switching options fits your goal now
4In-force illustration shows lapse before your target ageCurrent in-force illustrationRecalculate the premium needed to reach your target age
5Account value fell in a year the index credit was 0% or lowAnnual statementReview charges and funding level
6Policy loans are growing faster than cash valueAnnual statement; loan statementRepay loans, change loan type if allowed, slow withdrawals
7Original illustration used a cap rate higher than the insurer offers todayOriginal vs. current illustrationRe-illustrate at current and lower caps

General education only. Available fixes depend on each insurer’s contract and your state.

1. Are you paying only the minimum or target premium?

Paying the minimum or target premium is the most common sign an accumulation-focused IUL is underfunded. “Target premium” is largely an insurer and commission benchmark; it is not a promise that the policy will last or build meaningful cash value. If your goal was supplemental retirement income, the policy usually needs to be funded well above the minimum, within IRS limits.

2. Is the death benefit far larger than your goal needs?

A death benefit much larger than your goal requires raises the net amount at risk, which is roughly the death benefit minus the account value. The cost of insurance charge is calculated on that net amount at risk, so an oversized death benefit means more of each premium goes to insurance charges and less builds cash value. That is the right trade if protection is the main goal, and the wrong one if accumulation is.

3. Was the death benefit option ever revisited?

Most IULs offer a level death benefit (often called Option A) and an increasing death benefit (often called Option B). Accumulation-focused designs often start on the increasing option during funding years and later switch to level, which lowers the net amount at risk as cash value grows. A policy left on the increasing option for decades can keep cost of insurance charges higher than the plan intended. Whether a switch makes sense depends on your goal and contract.

4. Does your in-force illustration show the policy lapsing early?

An in-force illustration is the single best test of whether an IUL is on track. The NAIC’s life insurance illustrations guidance (updated January 8, 2026) describes in-force illustrations as periodic performance updates available after the first policy anniversary, at the insurer’s option or on the owner’s request. Wisconsin’s consumer alert recommends reviewing one every year and asking what premium would keep coverage in force to your desired date. If the illustrated column shows lapse before your target age, or the guaranteed column shows lapse within a few years, that’s a conversation to have now, not later.

5. Did your account value drop in a low-credit year?

An IUL’s 0% floor guarantees that credited interest won’t be negative in a crediting period, and that guarantee depends on the issuing insurer’s claims-paying ability. The floor protects credited interest, not the account value. Monthly charges still come out in a 0% year, so a meaningful drop in account value during a flat year is a sign that charges are heavy relative to funding.

6. Are policy loans outrunning your cash value?

Policy loans and withdrawals can be income-tax-free when the policy is structured and managed properly; this is not tax advice. A policy that lapses with a large loan outstanding can create a taxable event even if little cash comes back to you. If your loan balance is growing faster than your cash value, ask how much room the policy has left and whether the loan type you’re on (fixed or indexed, where offered) still fits.

7. Was it illustrated at a cap rate the insurer no longer offers?

IUL cap rates and participation rates are not guaranteed for the life of the policy, and insurers can change them within contract limits. If your original illustration assumed a higher cap than the one you’re being credited today, the original projections no longer describe your policy. The NAIC adopted Actuarial Guideline 49 in 2015 and AG 49-A for policies sold on or after December 14, 2020 to limit illustrated rates, with further disclosure revisions in 2026, but any illustration is still a hypothetical projection, not a guarantee. Ask to see your policy re-illustrated at today’s cap and at a lower cap.

How do you check your IUL in 15 minutes?

Gather three documents and answer four questions.

Documents: your policy data page, your most recent annual statement, and a current in-force illustration (request it from your insurer; Wisconsin’s alert says it can be requested annually free of charge).

Questions:

  1. What was this policy bought to do: protect a family, build cash value, or both?
  2. At my current premium, to what age does the illustrated column keep the policy in force?
  3. How did my account value change last year compared with the premiums I paid?
  4. What premium would keep the policy in force to my target age at a lower cap rate?

If any answer surprises you, the next step is a review, not a cancellation.

Should you replace or fix a poorly structured IUL?

Many poorly structured IULs can be improved without replacement, and many policies should be kept. Common in-place adjustments include changing the planned premium, reducing the face amount, switching the death benefit option, or changing how loans are taken, depending on what the contract allows.

Replacement can make sense in some cases, but it has real costs. Replacing a policy can trigger surrender charges on the old policy, require new medical underwriting, and start a new contestability period on the new one. A new policy also typically starts a new surrender charge schedule. That’s why any replacement should only happen when the numbers clearly favor it, and most states require a replacement notice comparing the two.

A policy review with me is free, and the most common outcome is a list of adjustments to discuss with your current insurer.

Who this is NOT for

This checklist and an IUL review are usually not the right next step for:

  • Someone who only needs coverage for a set number of years. If you need protection until a mortgage is paid or kids are grown, term life insurance is generally the lower-cost tool, and you may not need an IUL at all.
  • Anyone who can’t fund a permanent policy consistently. An IUL that can’t be funded tends to drift toward lapse no matter how it’s structured.
  • Someone looking for an investment. An IUL is life insurance. It doesn’t participate directly in the market, and credited interest is limited by caps and participation rates.
  • Owners who want a tax opinion. Questions about MEC status, loan taxation or surrender gains belong with a CPA or tax attorney; I can explain how the policy works and coordinate with them.

If you own an IUL and aren’t sure how it’s built, a short call can tell you which warning signs apply. Schedule a free call and bring your latest annual statement.

Frequently asked questions

What does it mean for an IUL to be structured correctly? A correctly structured IUL has a premium, death benefit and death benefit option that match the owner’s goal, and a current in-force illustration that shows the policy lasting to the target age at a premium the owner can keep paying.

Is paying the target premium on an IUL enough? Not always. Target premium is mainly an insurer and commission benchmark, and on an accumulation-focused IUL it is often well below what the policy needs to build cash value and stay in force long term. An in-force illustration shows whether your premium is enough.

How do I get an in-force illustration for my IUL? Call or write your insurer’s customer service and ask for an in-force illustration at your current premium. Regulators such as the Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance recommend requesting one every year.

Can you put too much money into an IUL? Yes. Under Internal Revenue Code Section 7702A, a policy funded above the 7-pay limit becomes a modified endowment contract (MEC), which changes how loans and withdrawals are taxed. A correctly structured accumulation IUL is typically funded close to, but under, that limit. This is not tax advice.

Should I cancel my IUL if it’s underfunded? Usually not before a review. Surrendering may trigger surrender charges and, if there are loans or gains, a tax bill, and replacing a policy can mean new underwriting and a new contestability period. Many underfunded policies can be adjusted instead.

Does a policy review cost anything? A policy review with Lenhoff Financial is free, and many policies are kept as they are after review.

About the author

Brandon Lenhoff is a licensed insurance agent and owner of Lenhoff Financial, Inc., a virtual independent insurance agency based in Lincoln, Nebraska and licensed across the U.S. He specializes in indexed universal life, fixed and fixed indexed annuities, MYGAs, mortgage protection and term life insurance, and he previously built and sold a mortgage protection agency. Phone: (402) 413-1351 · lenhofffinancial.com

Not sure how your IUL is built?

Send me your latest annual statement and we’ll walk through all seven warning signs together, at no cost and with no pressure to change anything. Schedule a free call.

Sources: Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance, Consumer Alert on Universal Life Insurance, December 3, 2021 (oci.wi.gov); NAIC, “Life Insurance Illustrations” insurance topic page, updated January 8, 2026 (content.naic.org); Internal Revenue Code §7702A.

Brandon Lenhoff
About Brandon Lenhoff

Brandon Lenhoff is a licensed insurance agent and the owner of Lenhoff Financial Inc. in Lincoln, Nebraska. His team helps families across the U.S. evaluate Indexed Universal Life, fixed indexed annuities and other life insurance solutions, and reviews existing policies.

More about Brandon · Schedule a call

Brandon Lenhoff is a licensed insurance agent with Lenhoff Financial Inc. Insurance products only; this article is for educational purposes and is not tax, legal or investment advice. Guarantees are backed by the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer.